Tuesday, November 29, 2022

Frustration continues to rise in the case of Marvin Scott, III’s death

On March 14, Marvin Scott, III died while in the custody of Collin County law enforcement officers. In the time since, family and friends have been trying to get answers and accountability for what happened.

They say they are hitting a brick wall when it comes to responses from the Collin County Sheriff’s office. The family and their supporters have pledged to keep up pressure on Collin County officials until their issues are resolved.
This led to a May 2 protest where an altercation between the protesters and a motorist delayed by the blocking of a roadway heated up and seemed to almost come to blows.
A video of the exchange has garnered more than 100,000 views on YouTube and has drawn comments condemning both the motorist and the protesters.
Even Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton has chimed in on the video, saying the protesters are the ones who should have been arrested, and implying that one motorist pulled out what appeared to be a gun.
A motorist faces off against protesters at an intersection in Plano during a demonstration related to the death of Marvin Scott, III while in custody in Collin County. The family is looking for accountability for what they believe was another example of a needless death at the hands of law enforcement. (Youtube screenshot)

Police later noted that the device was not a gun but a taser, and that the motorist had been charged with assault by contact, as he struck the hand of a protester while apparently trying to swipe a phone from her hand.

At Monday night’s city council meeting in Plano, several people addressed city leaders concerning the incident, with opinions ranging from those who feel the motorist should have been arrested, to others saying the police had not done enough to stop the “BLM agitators.”
One speaker who addressed the council regarding why the protest was held in the first place was disrupted and heckled by audience members in attendance, causing the mayor to intervene.
“The cognitive dissonance in here blows my mind,” the female speaker said.
Another speaker who appeared in public suggested Plano being spotlighted this way made it more likely that future protesters would want to come to Plano and try to disrupt the peace.

NDG 5/6: DOJ seeks to clean up police departments around the country

DOJ seeks to clean up police departments around the country

Prior to the public comments, Plano City Manager Mark Israelson  gave the council an update on the incident with more context than what was shared online in the past week.
He told the council the officer was originally dispatched to a traffic malfunction call. It was then the officer arrived that he discovered there was no malfunction, but that protesters were in the intersection following a planned event in Frisco. At that point, Israelson said the officer’s first priority was to de-escalate until other officer could arrive.
Because of the crowd, Israelson said the lone officer did not originally see the contact between the motorist and protesters. It was after conferring with both parties, as well as reviewing video of the incident, that the assault charge was filed.
He also said the blocking of the intersection only lasted approximately seven minutes.
The fallout from this event continues to draw attention to the Scott case, and a family’s efforts to find answers.

NDG 4/22: Reflections on a long, consequential trial

Reflections on a long, consequential trial

Scott had been arrested on marijuana charges following his interaction with officers from the Allen Police  Department outside an outlet mall. While in jail, officers said Scott began behaving strangely and was combative when they tried to restrain him.
Collin County’s chief medical examiner, Dr. William Rohr, listed the cause of death as “fatal acute stress response in an individual with previously diagnosed schizophrenia during restraint struggle with law enforcement.”
There were seven officers placed on leave and  then fired after the death of Scott. However, one of the officers has since been brought back to the facility.

NDG 4/15: ‘I just want my baby home’ says distraught mom of unarmed Black man killed by police


Elizabeth Michel, a family friend, has been looking for answers from the Sheriff as to why.
“Well, now you have an employee that you terminated for violating ‘well-established policies and procedures’ back working in that facility,” Michel wrote in an email. “So again, I ask you, what have you done to retrain, re-educate, and ensure that your officers know the training and follow the training? You are responsible for their behavior. What is your plan to fix this internally???”

As of press time, it was Michel’s sixth attempt to get answers to these questions from the Collin County Sheriff’s Office.


  1. Marvin Scott

    Marvin Scott (26 years old) was arrested for having less that 2 oz marijuana. Taken to Allen police dept- Taken to Allen Presby hospital- then sent to Collin county jail. He may have been having a schizophrenic episode by then. They restrained him, pepper sprayed him, did a choke hold and then multiple officers got on his back and then he died. ( this was over a 5 hour period) 7 officers were fired and one resigned immediately. Coroner said it was a homicide.
    Since then secrecy and lies. It took 45 days for family to see video (without audio) of their sons death- his father said he watched his son be tortured to death. Seems like whole thing is being ignored and swept under the rug.
    Have had like 40 peaceful protests. They have tried to get help from DA Willis, Ken Paxton AG (criminal but they don’t have the money to take him to court- charges from 5 years ago and then in 2020. ) Also a buddy of DA Greg Willis. Texas Rangers don’t seem to be able to help either!
    Instead Paxton went after one of the protests (big time- but no help to family for murdered son)when a policeman sided with protesters. Time marches by with the peaceful protests and going to the county commissioners every Monday where each one attending can speak for 3 minutes. There is no response from county commissioners court and still nothing happens.

    Now we have Ken Paxton, Chris Hill, Greg Willis going after the peaceful protestors calling them agitators and saying they will not put up with that!
    But still nothing happening about the murder of Marvin Scott!!
    What would you do if Marvin Scott was your son?


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here